There is no secret

10Afterward, when he was alone, his followers and the Twelve asked him about his parables, 11and he said, “To you the secret of the realm of God has been imparted; but to those who are outside everything takes the form of parables so that 12‘though they have eyes, they may see without perceiving; and though they have ears, they may hear without understanding; some day they might turn and be forgiven.'” 1

– Mark 4:10-12 (NNT 2)

In a Quaker study group I lead, two members voiced differing visceral responses to the parabolic storytelling of Jesus.

One newcomer was fascinated by the impenetrable mystery of these stories, and more so by the suggestion in Mark 12 that Jesus was deliberately confounding the people in his public speaking. One might infer that he was giving his disciples “secret teachings.”

The other person, a longtime Quaker but very much a skeptic, voiced vehement objection to all the parables. “They don’t make any sense. Why a father favor his no account slacker first born of the the younger son who stayed home and took care of him?” 3

Bure Peak Antenna

“Parable” is from the Latin para­bola and the Greek parabole, meaning “to throw beside, to compare.” Told in public, a parabolic story is something like a Zen koan. As Buddhist teacher John Tarrant explains,

A koan is a little healing story, a conversation, an image, a fragment of a song. It’s something to keep you company, whatever you are doing….

Koans don’t really explain things. Instead, they show you something by opening a gate. You walk through, and you take the ride.

In other words, a parable is something to jog your thinking—precisely because it doesn’t make sense according to conventional views.

Parables sneak up on you. My favorite is usually called “The Good Samaritan” (Luke 10:25-37), but most of us miss the point because we just read the story Jesus told the lawyer instead of the story about the lawyer.

As I’ve written elsewhere, 4 The lawyer, trying to catch Jesus up, asks, “who is my neighbor?” Jesus tells the parable and asks back, “Which of these three do you think was a neighbor to the man…?” The lawyer answers correctly and then walks off.

I always imagine him stopping at a distance and saying, “Wait a minute! He didn’t answer my question!”

That stopping at a distance is all that counts. That’s when we start unloading the baggage in the way of really seeing into ourselves.

That’s when, maybe, we recognize how the storyteller has laid a booby trap for us…one that we would be happy, if we only knew, to fall into.

That’s when we might let go of all preconceptions and, better, let go of all expectations for our own lives.

That’s when we might discover that there is no secret. Just a truth that our normal way of looking at things conceals.

Here is what I wrote in “Where to start,” the first post on this blog, in 2007:

I have always been wary of either the “right doctrine” of religious orthodoxies or the “secret knowledge” of ancient or modern gnosticisms.

My bone-deep conviction, arising from my childhood apprehension of the witness of Jesus, is that every human being has an intimate, unmediated and salutary relationship with what many of us call God.

That relationship cannot be one which depends upon living by right doctrine or secret knowledge. It is implicitly familial, a birthright which no human agency can grant or deny. Wherever there seem to be rifts or torments in the relationship, those arise from the misperceptions of human beings, not from the reality of God’s interrelationship with us.

This conviction seems to me also to be at the very heart of Quaker faith and practice. When those seekers in seventeenth century England lay aside scripture, liturgy and sacrament to “wait upon the Lord,” it was because they had come to recognize how finite and fallible any forms of human concept and language are when it comes to representing the living Truth of that divine interrelationship.

In effect they were saying: “If God is real, then only God’s own direct mediation with us is real. Anything else is transient, mortal.”

And so it is.
Blessèd Be,

Mike Shell

Notes & Image Sources

Image: “Bure Peak Antenna,” a parabolic antenna array on Pic de Bure the Dauphiné Alps in France. By claude05alleva (2016) on Pixabay [CC0 Creative Commons, free for commercial use, no attribution required].

  1. Isaiah 6:9-10

    19 He said, “Go and tell this people:

    ‘Be ever hearing, but never understanding;
    be ever seeing, but never perceiving.’

    10 Make the heart of this people calloused;
    make their ears dull
    and close their eyes.
    Otherwise they might see with their eyes,
    hear with their ears,
    understand with their hearts,
    and turn and be healed.”

  2. A New New Testament: A Bible for the 21st Century Combining Traditional and Newly Discovered Texts, edited with a commentary by Hal Taussig (2013)
  3. Luke 15:11-32 – Parable of the Lost Son
  4. Neighbor,” published on Quaker Universalist Conversations (8/30/2016)

2 comments On There is no secret

  • Alexander Doty

    Jesus seems to imply that “the secret of the realm of God” has been imparted only with the disciples. Your title implies that this is not the case. Is it their direct acquaintance with Jesus to which he refers and which to others comes through the parables?

    • Thanks for this, Alex. I think your second sentence does come close to what Jesus meant by “the secret of the realm of God.”

      In the latest session of our study group (see Session 6: Worshiping together), we spoke directly to the difficulty of explaining to others what we experience in the depth of silent worship. Group members took turns describing the physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual sensations they move through during “waiting worship.” But note, we were describing the sensations, not what they evoked inwardly, before concepts and words.

      Then one Friend told of experiencing a “covered meeting.” How does one explain such a collective sense of oneness to others? This example tries, but only by offering metaphors:

      “In a gathered meeting, as I have experienced it, it is impossible to draw away from the Divine. One is gladly caught and lifted up and knows that others are experiencing the same thing. Imagine the feeling of being…any concert where everyone is singing the same song with heartfelt joy. It’s like that, but deeper, much deeper and because it is a sense without words, it is known in a different part of ones being than the normal verbal places we inhabit most of the time.”

      – from

      In a sense, all Jesus could give the public was parables. You can’t talk about or hear about God’s realm. You have to do it.

      As I wrote this morning, the best parables can do is stop you up short and make you say, “Hey, wait a minute…!”

      Then, if you are curious—and spiritually hungry enough—you might sit down with Jesus, center down, and wait.

      Blessings, Mike

Comments are closed.

Site Footer

Verified by MonsterInsights